Multidisciplinarity in Law Firms in the Light of Ruling C-295/23 of the Court of Justice of the European Union

The ruling of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU), handed down on 19 December 2024 in case C-295/23 – Halmer Rechtsanwaltsgesellschaft UG v. Rechtsanwaltskammer München – represents a jurisprudential milestone in delimiting the contours of the admissibility of multidisciplinary corporate structures within the legal profession. The basic question – whether European Union law allows the legislation of a Member State to prohibit the holding of shares in law firms by investors who do not exercise any legal or equivalent profession – has direct implications for the legal modelling of the legal profession in all Member States.

Based on the interpretation of Articles 49 and 63 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU), relating to the freedom of establishment and the free movement of capital, and Article 15 of Directive 2006/123/EC (Services Directive), the CJEU analysed the compatibility of the German system – which prohibited the holding of shares in law firms by persons who are not members of the liberal professions subject to codes of ethics – with the EU legal system. The decision is of particular importance as it enshrines in consolidated case law that the principle of the independence of the legal profession can justify restrictions on the participation of purely financial actors in the profession’s corporate structures.

  1. The facts of the case and the legal question put to the CJEU

The dispute underlying case C-295/23 arose from the Munich Bar Association’s decision to revoke the registration of Halmer Rechtsanwaltsgesellschaft UG, after it sold 51% of its capital to an Austrian company (SIVE GmbH), which was not subject to any form of ethical regulation and had no intention of practising law. Despite the fact that the German law firm had included strict clauses in its articles of association to exclude any interference by non-lawyer partners in the activity of lawyers – in particular with regard to technical direction, client management, professional secrecy and compliance with ethical rules – the Bar Association took the view that this structure violated the legal framework in force, which imposes as a requirement for company membership the effective exercise of a legal or equivalent liberal profession, subject to ethics.

The national court, the Bayerischer Anwaltsgerichtshof, referred the question to the CJEU for a preliminary ruling, asking whether national legislation that excludes purely financial investors from the corporate composition of law firms, even if that exclusion implies restrictions on cross-border investment, complies with European Union law.

  1. The CJEU’s legal reasoning: between economic freedom and the protection of professional independence

In its decision, the CJEU carried out a meticulous analysis of the relationship between the fundamental principles of the internal market – namely the freedom of establishment and the free movement of capital – and the overriding reasons of public interest recognised by its own case law and provided for in the Services Directive. The Court concluded that the restrictions imposed by the German legislator were legitimate, proportionate and necessary and did not violate European law.

The CJEU’s reasoning was based on three fundamental pillars:

  1. The admissibility of non-discriminatory restrictions: the legislation in question did not discriminate on grounds of nationality and applied uniformly to all investors, whether national or foreign.

  2. The justification on the grounds of overriding reasons in the public interest: the Court recognised that the need to protect the independence of lawyers, to guarantee professional secrecy and to preserve the proper administration of justice constitutes sufficient grounds for limiting economic freedom, under Article 15(3) of Directive 2006/123/EC.

  3. Proportionality of the restrictive measure: The CJEU rejected the argument that statutory clauses – such as those adopted by Halmer – were sufficient to guarantee functional independence. It argued that the mere risk of influence, even indirectly, from an investor unrelated to the legal profession, with purely lucrative interests, is enough to jeopardise ethical principles and public confidence in the legal profession.

The decision is thus based on a structuralist view of the legal profession, in which the public function of the legal profession, as a guarantor of justice and legality, takes precedence over the purely mercantile logic of access to the market.

III. The Portuguese legal system: convergence with the solution validated by the CJEU

The Portuguese legal system broadly adopts the same understanding enshrined in the CJEU judgement. The Statute of the Portuguese Bar Association, approved by Law no. 145/2015, expressly states that law firms may adopt a multidisciplinary structure, but only with professionals subject to ethical rules equivalent to those of the legal profession.

Article 213(7) of the Statute is unequivocal:

‘Only professionals subject to professional organisations or public associations that impose duties of ethics and professional secrecy compatible with those of lawyers may join law firms.’

This requirement ensures that the firm’s activity is not captured by external economic interests and that its members are bound by the same ethical and functional logic that governs the profession. The participation of financial investors outside the regulated universe of the liberal professions is therefore implicitly excluded.

In this regard, reference should be made to the view reiterated by the Portuguese Bar Association, which considers any structure that jeopardises the technical and ethical independence of lawyers to be unacceptable, as expressed in doctrinal opinions and internal regulations.

  1. Comparative models in the European Union: diversity under a common principle

A comparison of the legal models adopted by EU member states reveals a common matrix for safeguarding the independence of the legal profession, but with significant nuances in terms of the degree of corporate openness:

  • Germany: restrictive regime, although extended after 2022 to cover other liberal professions (engineers, doctors, architects), but not open to purely financial entities.

  • France: allows interprofessional companies, as long as lawyers retain control of the management and the majority of the capital.

  • Spain: allows multidisciplinary organisations but limits the participation of non-lawyers and requires a legal majority in management.

  • Netherlands: more liberal, allowing private capital participation (including funds), but requiring strict functional safeguards regarding professional autonomy.

According to data from the Council of Bars and Law Societies of Europe (CCBE):

– 57% of countries allow multidisciplinary companies controlled by lawyers;

– 29% allow minority participation by non-legal professionals;

– Only 14%, like the Netherlands, welcome financial investors under reinforced regulatory mechanisms.

This data confirms that the Portuguese position is in line with the majority of Member States, aligning itself with the paradigm validated by the CJEU in the judgement under analysis.

  1. Legal doctrine: foundations and academic reception

National and European legal literature has consistently reaffirmed the unique role of the legal profession as a function of public interest. Authors such as António Menezes Cordeiro emphasise that the legal profession, although practised privately, ‘assumes a parafunctional nature, being subordinated to principles of public interest, such as access to justice and technical independence’.

Similarly, Guy Canivet, a former member of the French Conseil Constitutionnel, argued at CCBE colloquia that ‘independence is not just a personal quality of the lawyer, but a structural characteristic of the profession that cannot be alienated from financial logic’.

The CJEU’s decision thus reinforces this doctrinal understanding, placing normative brakes on the possible financialization of the legal profession that could compromise its constitutional mission.

 

  1. Conclusion

The CJEU’s judgement in case C-295/23 unequivocally clarifies that EU law does not require Member States to open up law firms to unrestricted financial investment, and that it is legitimate to make corporate participation conditional on compliance with ethical standards and the effective practice of the profession. The ruling reaffirms the special nature of the legal profession, whose institutional role requires real and not just formal autonomy from interests other than justice.

By enshrining a model of controlled multidisciplinarity, Portugal confirms itself as legally compliant with European law and politically prudent, preserving the dignity of the profession without ignoring the demands of adapting to the new challenges of the legal market.

This decision not only validates the national system, but also sets a clear benchmark for future legislative reforms, ensuring that the necessary modernisation of the practice of law does not compromise its ethical and social foundations.

 

References:

A holding by purely financial investors in a law firm may be prohibited

Acórdão do Tribunal de Justiça (Grande Secção), de 19.12.2024